• 84 Posts
  • 1.14K Comments
Joined 2 年前
cake
Cake day: 2023年7月9日

help-circle













  • Massive environmental harms

    I find this questionable; people forget that a locally-hosted LLM is no more taxing than a video game.

    So read and learn.

    No chance it’s going to get better

    Why do you believe this? It has continued to get dramatically better over the past 5 years. Look at where GPT2 was in 2019.

    Fair enough. It’s not going to get better because the fundamental problem is AI as represented by, say, ChatGPT doesn’t know anything. It has no understanding of anything it’s “saying”. Therefore, any results derived from ChatGPT or equivalent, will need to be double-checked in any serious endeavor. So, yes it can poop out a legal brief in two seconds but it still has to be revised, refined, and inevitably fixed when it hallucinates precedent citations and just about anything else. That, the core of it, will never get better. It might get faster. It might “sound” “more human”. But it won’t get better.

    No profitable product […] Tens of thousands of (useful!) careers terminated

    Do you not see the obvious contradiction here? If you are sure that this is not going to get better and it’s not profitable, then you have nothing to worry about in the long-term about careers being replaced by AIs.

    Well tell that to the half a million people laid off in the last couple of years. Damage is done. Also, the bubble is still growing, and if you haven’t noticed what AI has done to the HR industry, let me summarize it thusly: it has destroyed it.

    Destroyed Internet search, arguably the one necessary service on the Internet

    Google did this intentionally as part of enshittification.

    Well, yes. Every company which has chosen to promote and focus on AI has done so intentionally. That doesn’t mean it’s good. If AI wasn’t the all-hype vaporware it is, this wouldn’t have been an option. If OpenAI had been honest about it and said “it’s very interesting and we’re still working on it” instead of “it’s absolutely going to change the world in six months” this wouldn’t be the unusable shitpile it is.