Isreal is committing a genocide right now, and has been maintaining an apartheid state for decades. In this analogy, they’re the white South Africans. They’re the nazis.
Black South African leadership did not express a desire to kill all whites. Hamas have expressed a desire to kill all Jews in the Levant so the analogy does not hold.
It’s not. It’s the very conception of the state of Israel. It was funded through the Naqba, a forcible relocation of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. The very idea of the modern state of Israel is genocidal and an apartheid ethnostate
Hitler famously inspired his Lebensraum theory in the US example and the Manifest Destiny doctrine. The US successfully genocided almost the entirety of native Americans. So yes, I would make a similar claim for the USA
Not every jew is a zionist. Don’t conflate the two. Israel does not have a right to exist, and jews do.
Where should the Israel Jews go now though?
Same place the Germans went after the holocaust ended. Same place the white South Africans went after their apartheid ended.
Most surviving German Jews went to the Levant (bear in mind that ⅔ were killed by Nazis).
White South Africans didn’t experience genocide.
Isreal is committing a genocide right now, and has been maintaining an apartheid state for decades. In this analogy, they’re the white South Africans. They’re the nazis.
Whether or not Israel has a right to exist, it is a childish fantasy to imagine it will vanish.
Black South African leadership did not express a desire to kill all whites. Hamas have expressed a desire to kill all Jews in the Levant so the analogy does not hold.
You want to force Jews into the diaspora again? Brilliant move, that worked so well for them the first time around. /s
So, the only alternative to diaspora is an apartheid ethnostate in occupied land?
of course not. the alternative should be a free and open society where Jews are but one of many groups.
Israel is currently sliding away from this - sadly - but it still has the potential
It’s not. It’s the very conception of the state of Israel. It was funded through the Naqba, a forcible relocation of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians. The very idea of the modern state of Israel is genocidal and an apartheid ethnostate
would you also claim the same for the United States? Their original sin is even darker, as most natives did not move away but simply died.
Iriginal sin is not necessarily destiny.
Hitler famously inspired his Lebensraum theory in the US example and the Manifest Destiny doctrine. The US successfully genocided almost the entirety of native Americans. So yes, I would make a similar claim for the USA